testimony

Chapter 7 - The Lie About Catherine's Death

The icebox was empty.

Not just empty of food.

Empty of the shelves that should have been inside it.

The kitchen looked the way somebody leaves a room when they believe they will return. There were three blue mugs on the rack. A pencil rested beside a recipe for lemon cake. On the wall, somebody had drawn Sophie's height in crooked lines and written her age beside each one. The last mark was from the summer before Catherine died.

I touched nothing. I wanted to memorize everything.

"She made this place herself," Luca said softly. "When we bought the furniture, she insisted nothing had to match. She said matching rooms looked like hotels."

He pointed toward a yellow chair beneath the window. "She spent two weeks sanding that thing. I thought she was wasting her time."

"Did she?"

"No. She was happy. I just couldn't see why a chair mattered so much."

I looked at him. "Maybe she liked making something last."

He nodded, his eyes fixed on the chair.

There was no dramatic music, no sudden revelation. Just a man who'd been taught to command an empire standing in a kitchen he'd never truly appreciated while the woman who made it warm was gone.

I wondered how many other things he'd missed because he hadn't understood their value until too late.

There were four fresh screw marks along the back panel and a clean rectangular patch where dust had been disturbed. Whoever had opened it knew exactly what they were looking for.

I gripped the back of a kitchen chair.

"We came too late."

"Maybe," Daniel said. "Or somebody came looking and left without finding it. We don't know which."

Luca stood motionless in front of the cabinet. His reflection flickered in the old glass of the window.

"Catherine loved this thing," he said. "She bought it at an estate sale because the seller said it had survived two world wars. I spent half a weekend trying to fix the latch."

"And did you?" I asked.

He gave a short laugh. "No. She did. She fixed it herself while I was on the phone."

I looked at the bent copper catch.

"Was there a false bottom?"

"Not that I remember."

Daniel examined the cabinet without moving it. The local officer documented the marks, and Ellis, listening by phone, asked for photographs of the screws and surrounding floor.

Then I saw something the others had missed.

A thin line of blue paint curved beneath the bottom edge. It wasn't on the floor. It was on a second piece of wood fitted under the cabinet.

"Is that part of the icebox?"

Luca crouched, careful not to touch it.

The painted shape resembled the tip of a bird's wing.

"Catherine painted birds everywhere," he said.

"Yes," I replied. "But she chose where to paint them."

The officer photographed the panel, and Daniel asked him to preserve it for a formal examination. We couldn't know whether it held anything. We'd already learned how easily a confident guess could turn into a dangerous mistake.

While they worked, Luca walked to the window overlooking the lake.

I followed, stopping a few feet away.

"Did you ever ask how she died?" I said quietly.

He looked at me sharply.

"Of course."

"I mean whether the official story made sense to you."

The muscles in his jaw tightened.

"They said she lost control on a wet road. She was driving back from here in heavy rain. The car hit a barrier. The report said speed was a contributing factor."

"Did she drive fast?"

"Never with Sophie. Alone, sometimes. But she'd called me an hour earlier and said she was bringing something home. She sounded frightened."

He stared at the gray water.

"I told her to wait until morning. She said she couldn't. I was at a meeting. I promised I'd call back."

"Did you?"

"No."

A long silence passed between us.

"After she died, I kept thinking that if I'd answered the next call, she'd still be here."

I knew that kind of guilt. When my father had his heart attack, I had been at a friend's house. For years, I believed the right phone call, the right minute, the right decision might have saved him.

"You don't know that," I said.

"No," Luca answered. "I don't."

It was the first time I'd heard him allow uncertainty into his grief.

Daniel came to the window with his phone.

"Luca, the trust's former accountant has agreed to speak with Detective Ellis. Her name is Eleanor Brooks. She resigned two weeks before Catherine's crash."

"Why did she leave?"

"She says she was threatened after refusing to sign one of the winter transfers."

Luca's face closed.

"Who threatened her?"

"Victor's office. She kept the email."

We returned to Chicago that evening. My mother was comfortable in the temporary apartment. Patricia reported that Teresa had slept through the night after testing her call button twice. Sophie had spent the afternoon drawing a birdhouse with Mrs. Carter.

For a few hours, life almost felt ordinary.

Then I saw the photograph in Daniel's conference room.

It showed Catherine's car the morning after the crash. A black sedan twisted against a highway barrier. The front end was crushed. Rainwater shimmered on the road.

Daniel had obtained the original case materials through the appropriate records process. Ellis was reviewing them with a traffic reconstruction specialist because Catherine's new evidence raised questions, not because anyone had proved murder.

"The original file describes brake failure as undetermined," he said. "But the public summary says loss of control."

"Why the difference?" Luca asked.

"The car was badly damaged. The investigator couldn't rule out a mechanical problem. The report also notes the vehicle had been serviced the previous day."

I glanced at Luca.

His face was unreadable.

"Who authorized the service?" he asked.

Daniel pointed to a maintenance receipt.

VICTOR BELLINI HOLDINGS—FLEET DIVISION.

Nobody spoke.

Finally, Luca said, "Catherine's car was private. Why would Victor's company service it?"

"We don't know," Daniel replied. "Ellis is trying to establish whether the receipt is genuine and who actually worked on the vehicle."

I thought of Vanessa's warning about the bell. Victor knows everything.

But evidence didn't become proof just because it made our hearts race. We needed people who could explain what happened, records that could be verified, and someone willing to tell the truth when it cost them.

During the drive back, Daniel received an update about the foundation's grants. One recipient organization was supposed to have operated a child care program in three neighborhoods. Public records showed no employees, no licensed facility, and no evidence of children ever receiving services. The supposed director was registered to an address used by another shell company.

"I know numbers can be made to say all kinds of things," I told Daniel. "But how does someone hide that much money?"

"One transaction at a time," he replied. "Often through paperwork that seems routine until someone compares the contracts with what was actually delivered."

He reminded me of the care invoices. Patricia's thirteen missing shifts were smaller than four million dollars, but the principle was the same. A promise written on paper could hide an absence in real life. A person signed a form saying help had been provided; someone else looked at the form instead of the empty room.

"Catherine must have seen it," I said.

"She was asking the right questions," Daniel replied.

I thought of her letters in Sophie's bedroom. She hadn't left behind a grand speech. She'd left small directions, tiny pieces of herself, because she knew one person might not get the chance to explain everything.

That kind of courage was quieter than Luca's reputation. It might also have been stronger.

That night, Eleanor Brooks called the detective again.

She wasn't willing to come to the mansion. She wasn't willing to meet Luca. But she agreed to make a recorded statement in a neutral office with her attorney present.

I wasn't in the room for the interview. Daniel told us only what Eleanor authorized him to share afterward.

She'd found foundation funds routed into a shell company connected to Victor. Catherine confronted her about a signature Eleanor insisted was forged. Catherine then hired an independent auditor.

"What happened to the auditor?" Luca asked.

Daniel looked at the floor.

"He disappeared from the records after the accident. The firm closed six months later."

"What's his name?"

"Simon Kessler."

The name meant nothing to me.

It meant something to Luca.

His expression turned cold.

"Kessler handled security contracts for my father," he said. "He wasn't just an auditor."

Daniel nodded.

"Eleanor says Catherine hired him because he knew how money moved between the old businesses."

Luca pressed his fingers against his eyes.

The room was quiet for so long that I heard the clock ticking over the fireplace.

Then Daniel's phone buzzed.

A message from the forensic laboratory.

May you like

The memory card from Teresa's bell was readable.

And its first recovered file was a recording dated the night before Catherine died.

Related Stories

Other posts